What Results Can My Store Expect from Email Marketing?
Updated: 3 days ago
If you run an online store taking £5,000 to £20,000 a month, email marketing can realistically bring in 20 to 40% of your revenue. One of my clients, a UK gardening brand, now takes 58% of their online store revenue through email. Almost all of it comes from automations that run in the background every single day.
What Results Can My Store Expect from Email Marketing?
I've spent over 20 years in retail with brands like Primark, Next and Marks and Spencer, and the last 10 years in e-commerce and digital marketing. I've helped over 100 e-commerce businesses grow their sales, and I'm a Klaviyo Bronze partner who also works hands-on with Omnisend and Mailchimp.
In this post I'll show you what email marketing can do for your store, how long it takes to work, and the mistakes I see holding small brands back.
The Short Answer: 20 to 40% Of Your Revenue
When a store owner asks me what email marketing will do for their business, my honest answer is that it can bring in up to 40% of your store sales. For a store taking £10,000 a month, that is up to £4,000 coming from customers who already know you.
That is what makes email different from paid ads. You've already paid to get those people to your site. Email marketing is how you bring them back without paying for every click again.
But most small brands are nowhere near that figure, and it is rarely because email doesn't work for them. It is because of how their email account has been set up.
What I Usually Find When I Open A New Client's Email Account
When I log into a new client's Klaviyo, Omnisend or Mailchimp account, the same three problems come up repeatedly.
Campaigns Go Out When There's Time
Many brands don't send email campaigns consistently. They send three in one week, then nothing for a month. That stop-start pattern is often one of the causes behind the ups and downs in their sales.
Automations That Could Belong To Any Brand
The automated flows are there, but they are generic. They use the platform's default wording and design, with nothing that tells the customer who you are or why your products are different. A customer who abandons a basket should get an email that feels like your brand, not a template.
Far Too Many Flows
One client I worked with had 16 flows set up. When I went through them, everything they were trying to do could have fitted into four or five. Customers were getting the same emails repeatedly from different flows.
That doesn't just annoy people. When customers keep receiving repeat emails, they start marking them as junk, and that damages your deliverability for every email you send afterwards.
Case Study: How A UK Gardening Brand Went From 10% to 58%
The best way to show you what email can do is with real numbers from a client I'm working with right now.
Where They Started
This UK gardening brand was already using Omnisend, but they didn't really know how to get the most out of it. In the first five months of the year, email brought in just 10% of their online store revenue.
What I Changed
In June, I rebuilt all their automated flows from scratch. I also planned a three-month campaign schedule to carry them through their peak season, so they weren't scrambling for something to send each week.
The Results
Since June, email marketing has gone from 10% to 58% of their online store revenue. And 97% of that email revenue now comes from four basic automations:
• Welcome flow
• Abandoned cart flow
• Browse abandonment flow
• Post-purchase flow
The rest of their numbers moved in the same direction:
• Open rates went from 31% to an average of 46%
• Click-through rate went from 5.7% to 6.3%
• Placed order rate doubled from 1.2% to 2.4%
• Average order value from email is now 32% higher than from their other channels
In the old setup, the welcome series was the only flow that actually converted. Now every flow except one is producing sales. The post-purchase flow has become the strongest of the lot, and it is bringing repeat customers back to the store.
Nothing about this was complicated. We didn't add fancy tools or send more emails. We took the flows they already had and made them work properly.
How Long Does It Take To See Results?
Expect it to take up to three months to see real results from email marketing. Some stores see changes sooner, but three months is a fair timeframe for flows to bed in and for campaigns to build momentum.
Two things speed it up: the size of your list and how often you have something new to talk about. A steady stream of new products gives you a natural reason to email your customers.
Check Your Open Rate First
Before anything else, look at your current open rate. You want it above 20%. Once you are there, your deliverability improves, which means fewer of your emails end up in spam filters.
Even with a small list, hitting a 20 to 30% open rate is a good sign that things are heading in the right direction.
If You Have A Small List
With only a few hundred subscribers, results take longer to show because there are fewer people to sell to. Focus on getting your automations right and your open rate up. Those foundations pay off as your list grows.
If You Have A Large List
With a bigger list, email can have a much quicker effect. Start by cleaning your list so you are only emailing people who are genuinely engaged. Then you can begin emailing them straight away with offers and educational content that turns subscribers into paying customers.
The Flows That Do The Heavy Lifting
Automated flows are where most of your email revenue will come from. Remember, 97% of my gardening client's email revenue comes from four of them
.
If You Only Have Time For Two, Start Here
If you can only set up two flows this week, make them your welcome flow and your abandoned cart flow. The people entering these flows are the customers most likely to buy, so they are where you'll see results first.
Once they are live, A/B test both with small tweaks. Try a different subject line, a different opening image or a different call to action, and keep what works.
What Goes Into A Post-Purchase Flow That Works
For smaller brands, I keep the post-purchase flow to two or three emails at most:
• Email one: thank them for their order. This will be the most opened email in any of your sequences, because the customer has already taken action. Use it to send them back to the store to explore other products and different sections of your range.
• Email two: ask for a review. This shows the customer you still remember their order, and it builds the social proof that helps your next customer decide to buy.
• Email three (optional): show them something new. Depending on the brand, a third email can showcase new products or collections the customer didn't buy from the first time.
It is a simple structure, but it was the post-purchase flow that became my gardening client's strongest performer.
Email Marketing Mistakes That Hold Small Brands Back
Some of the beliefs I hear from store owners cost them more sales than any technical issue.
Worrying About Emailing Too Often
Yes, you can email too much. A small brand sending 15 to 20 emails a week is overdoing it. But most small brands make the opposite mistake and barely email at all.
In my opinion, even a small brand should be sending two to three email campaigns per week. Your customers signed up to hear from you, so give them a reason to stay engaged.
Putting A Discount In Every Email
If every email you send has a discount code, your customers will learn to wait for one. Eventually they will never buy at full price. Mix offers with new products, educational content and brand stories so a discount still feels like something special.
Buying An Email List
Never buy an email list. Those people never asked to hear from you, so they ignore your emails or mark them as spam. It is one of the quickest ways to get your brand a bad reputation with email providers, and that hurts every email you send to your genuine customers.
Which Email Platform Should You Use?
The right platform matters less than how well you use it. But cost is something every small brand needs to keep an eye on.
Watch What You're Paying For
Most email platforms charge per subscriber, so costs can mount up quickly. Your list will almost certainly include junk email addresses and people who haven't opened an email in a year.
I knew a brand that was spending over $700 a month on email subscribers they weren't even emailing. Look at how many contacts you're paying for, then look at how many you actually send to.
Klaviyo, Omnisend Or Mailchimp
As a Klaviyo Bronze partner, I can tell you Klaviyo offers the best automation and segmentation on the market. It is also a costly platform, and that is worth knowing before you sign up.
Omnisend and Mailchimp are good alternatives. In my opinion their segmentation isn't as strong, but they will do the job well for many smaller brands. There are also a couple of smaller platforms I've worked with that are excellent value. They aren't big names yet, but I expect them to be in the next 12 to 18 months.
Don't Switch Platforms For The Sake Of It
My advice is usually to work with the platform you already have. Migrating to a new one is like starting an ad account from the ground up, and you lose a lot of the learning you've built.
Stay where you are until you are much bigger, unless your email health score is poor. That is when a move can make sense, and it is something I'll tell you straight if I see it.
The Mistake I Made With My First Store
Over 10 years ago, when I launched Capsuleight, my first Shopify store, I was learning e-commerce and marketing for the first time. We didn't ask people to sign up to an email list.
We were running paid traffic to the site, and the only emails those visitors received were Shopify's generic abandoned cart emails, with no branding at all. We were paying to bring people in and then letting them walk away. Worst of all, we weren't building a long-term list, which is one of the most valuable things a small brand can own.
That is the one thing I want you to take from this post. Set up an email platform and start capturing emails the day your site goes live. Every visitor who leaves without giving you their email is a customer you'll have to pay to reach again.
Should You Run Email Yourself Or Bring Someone In?
You can absolutely set up the basics yourself. But the numbers in this post show what happens when someone with real retail and customer experience knowledge takes over.
Your customers' inboxes are noisy. In my experience, most emails only get opened around 20% of the time, so yours need to stand out from every other brand competing for attention. Knowing how customers think and buy is what turns an email that gets ignored into one that gets opened and clicked.
If your site is live and you have no email capture, or your flows are generic and underperforming, get in touch with me as soon as possible. I'll get basic flows live quickly, so you stop losing sales, then rework them into automations built around your brand. Done properly, email can bring in 20 to 40% of your revenue within three months.

Comments